The lack of actual baseball IQ & knowledge is shocking for guys that spend this much time doing a podcast on the Yankees…. It’s like listening to two very uninformed baseball fan talking at the bar or on the Francesca show. Don’t waste your time

I finally unsubscribed after a podcast following a 4-2 road trip where the prevailing sentiment is “hitting home runs is not fun baseball” and “the win shouldn’t count because of it” followed by “I trust Ryan Yarbrough more than Carlos Rodon.” This show became WFAN at some point and I simply cannot do it anymore. Too bad as I loved this show for years.

Great podcast. My favorite Yankee podcast ! Really enjoy their analysis.

I’m a huge Dodgers fan but these guys really know baseball and they are not “homers”. I learned a ton about the Yankees lineup and even about baseball. Keep it up! The last 3x the dodgers played the Yanks in the WS the losing team won the first two, I was at all of those games in LA.

I looked forward to this show but not anymore. Andrew is such a cry baby, even wins aren’t good enough for this guy. Foh

Maybe learn how to let other people speak. Holy **** like take turns. Instead of always trying to cut off the other person.

I was shocked as was listening for the first time and heard the Gleyber discussion. I have no problem with strong criticism of a player and his stats but my jaw dropped when I heard one of you say “Did you see his face last night? That’s the face of a LOSER.” That’s an appalling statement. Being mean and nasty is your right but I have chosen not to listen to the show again. There’s plenty of people spewing hate in the world and I choose not to listen to people who are hurtful to others when I’m listening to the Yankees. Again, let me state that if the Yankees are playing poorly they each deserve harsh criticism and I have no problem with that but hurtful talk is not appropriate in my opinion. I’ll also say that a loser would be arrogantly not being upset when playing poorly. Gleyber clearly is suffering and probably feels horrible about his performance. I give him credit for sitting there in public knowing he’s doing so poorly. I haven’t heard him make excuses or lash out at anyone.

Informative and fun to listen to! Eric S.

New listener but just listened to a 45 minute o’s podcast when there’s a ton going on in the world of the Yankees. I’d understand if you were putting out several pods a week but at once a week and no Yankees talk is wild as a new listener…

Love these guys just wish they would ease off on the language a bit as I’d love to have my 9 year old grandson listen in but they inevitably drop an unnecessary F bomb. Thought since they both now have kids this might click with them

Per A. Rizzo & G. Stanton; they're 'channeling' R. S. In every respect. "Embarrassing" is too tame an assessment, disgusting & woeful too can only be further qualified as pathetic. "Good intention, without wisdom always accomplishes the wrong thing". '23 - so far - underscore's the above. And, it may be simply time passing, age advancing & entropy ensuing. Thank you for an objective analysis of Yankees Baseball - R. A. Coffee too. Go Yankees! J. L. Urquhart Boiee, Idaho

Love your podcast, and listened to your history of Yankee Stadium. You ask if John McGraw was a Yankees owner. He was. The book ‘Where They Ain’t’ about the 1890’s Baltimore Orioles is a great backstory about how they became the Yankees, and why McGraw later left for the Giants. Plus interesting info for Willie Keeler and Jack Chesbro and others. A great book if you haven’t read it yet. Go Yankees! Looks like it could be a wonderful season! @danquinlin

I don’t get to chat too much with other Yankee fans here in California, but I get my fill by listening to every episode of this podcast. Great insights, analysis, and just fun banter back and forth. Keep up the good work fellas, let’s go Yankees.

Guy in AA better than a gold glove winner who hit 260?

Listen to a lot of Yankees podcasts religiously and this is in my top 3 no question. The guys are entertaining, knowledgeable, and tell it how it is. Definitely deserves a listen (:

I listened to your soccer conversation and ended up listening to them through the whole World Cup. Because I am a fan of the Yankees, America and Soccer.

A baseball podcast, more specifically a Yankees podcast, in a recent episode, spent over 25 minutes trying to convince us to watch soccer. Seriously? Done with these guys.

Been listening for a few years so this is well deserved. Great job boys!

Awesome podcast

I live in norcal and hearing news and rants about the bombers keeps me connected. Scott is level headed and Andrew is the emotional Rollercoaster. and thanks to Logan and the crew for always bringing the receipts (stats in a moment)

In depth baseball knowledge, Yankees fans yet incredibly objective, great chemistry, each episode is entertaining and insightful..

Lots of interesting analysis. Focused Yankees talk with little to no stupid, off-topic chitchat.

I blame the Phish fans being in town for the garbage being thrown in right field 🤣🐠

10/10 podcast, love baseball and love the Yankees and the guys are so fun to listen to. Keep up the hard work, Go Yanks!

This is sometimes the best baseball pod out there, even if you’re not a Yankees fan. However it’s like these compete to see who can talk over who the most. And Scott, you don’t have to try and say everything your are trying to say as fast as you can. Finally Andrew, dude gather your thoughts before speaking! I’ve never heard someone fumble through words as much as you.

Great podcast for everyone from a casual listener to a super enthusiastic fan. Conversations and interviews are easy to follow, topics and ideas are explained very thoroughly, and Andrew and Scott have a great rapport. 👍

Living in Oregon there is no Yankees news. So when I do get some I can get a great analysis from them and they are spot on the way I feel as a fan Thanks

Great podcast - good mix of expertise and fandom. Thanks guys

I’ve been listening to this Podcast since 2017. Andrew and Scott have helped me keep my sanity through these agonizing last few seasons. This show is amazing!! Keep up the great work guys!!

These strokes no nothing about baseball.

I’m a Rays fan but I listen this to this podcast occasionally and these guys do a great job. It’s basically baseball bar talk with a couple guys that know the game well and are passionate about their team. Much better compared to other baseball podcasts which just tend to be nerds with talking heads.

I really appreciate their thoughtful, in depth, passionate analysis. I live in Cincinnati where baseball talk is about the size of the Yankees’ payroll and how the Reds can’t afford to keep up. Listening to Andrew & Scott reminds me of the conversations I had with my buddies back in the Bronx.

This would be a great podcast if the hosts didn’t stutter and fumble over their words continuously.

Who knows! But at least we can count on a real down to Earth Yankee podcast each week.

I’m a big fan of BP…and especially this year when we all share the same extreme disappointment at how $200 million can be squandered on putting together this uninspiring team.

I enjoy listening to Andrew and Scott talking Yankees baseball. Good or Bad they are always honest when breaking down everything about the Yankees. Keep up the great work guys. Go Yankees

This is the best Yankees podcast. The guys do such a great and honest job about breaking down everything going on in Yankees world. Keep up the good work!

Go Yanks! But I’m a Talkn Yanks fan.

I’ve been listening since 2017, and living in LA I am surrounded by Dodger fans and don’t have any other Yankee fans to talk to so listening to these shows every week really make me feel like I get to connect with other fans about anything and everything Yankees! Scott and Andrew are amazing host, keep it up! Go Yankees!

One of the best ever. Live in FL now. Wish I could be at the game tonight in the Bronx. Favorite NYY podcast. Go Yanks.

Hands down the best yanks pod. Lively conversation and good analysis from a couple diehards. I have tried a lot of Yankees podcasts and this one is the most entertaining for sure.

By far the best podcast out there for fans of the Bronx Bombers, I’ve been listening for 400+ episodes now and you guys just keep growing and making the show better. I appreciate your hard work!

Both Scott & Andrew provide a very informative and entertaining podcast. They bring new insite into the broad and complex realm of the New York Yankees. Keep up the excellent work, gentlemen! GO YANKEES!!!

Scott, Andrew, please don’t kill me. Just had the opportunity to rate/review cause I had android. The BPS is the best Yankees podcast produced.

Scott and Andrew have been one of the first ones to do it. I even used to read Andrew’s story’s at LoHud News. Great guys with a great pod

These guys are the best in the biz. Love the show!

Absolutely LOVE this podcast! You guys are great. The balance between analytics and eye test is fantastic... Please do not increase live shows. I listen here to avoid the takes of the general caller

Love the pod, but there’s not nearly enough talk about the exceptional Raul Ibanez. Clean it up, boys. See ya at the next event!

The guys touch on everything worth talking about

This is one of the best baseball shows if not the best. Scott and Andrew know the sport very well. Every week I look forward to tis podcast. This is a podcast that gets the fans and is amazing.