I get why you guys want guests on the show, but no Islander fan cares what Rachel Doerrie or Colby Cohen, etc. think about a team they don’t watch. It’s one thing to get other voices on, but another to listen to Stefen try to impress other fringe hockey media people.

Easily the best islanders podcast out there. Keep it going!

If you love the Isles, this weekly podcast is a must. The hosts are professional, reliable and well-informed, but refuse to take themselves too seriously. Easily my favorite podcast. Keep up the great work, boys!

sean and stef go all in on islanders. no other hockey pods hit the tongue in cheek, snark and humor that is being an islanders fan quite like these guys. good dudes. good pod! well deserving of the 5 stars. if you’re not doing the chickpea salad from blue line, you’re doing it wrong! LFGI.

There are a lot of fan podcasts that mean well and are sincere but are so raw and unpolished that they get annoying. This is a fan podcast with great guest, quality content, and production value A must have if you follow the isles

A well-earned five stars from me. I’ve listened to a lot of islanders podcasts in the past couple of years since I’ve become a big fan of the team. I truly appreciate the fact that these guys aren’t doomers! They also provide fair coverage and when they call a player out, it’s done in a thoughtful, balanced way. Overall, they are optimistic and positive, which is why I enjoy listening to them. I also love that they choose to advertise for local businesses — I now have some new places to check out. Thanks for keeping it light and fun. It is refreshing to me!

A must listen for any islanders fan. Great analysis, funny banter, and relevant insightful guests. Just met them at Blue Line bagel and couldn’t have been nicer. Great show fellas - keep up the quality work for us Isles fans.

News, analysis and entertainment. What else do you want?

Sean and Christian do a great job talkin isles hockey every week. They have great guests which really give fantastic insight about the isles and their opponents. This is a must listen for any diehard isles fan.

Big hockey guy. Big ranger fan. I don’t have time to catch a lot of Islander games and have grown to love Sean and Christian. Love to catch-up on the local team with you guys. Keep it coming.

These guys are very entertaining to listen to. Keep it up!

Hands down the best hockey talk around.

As former Long Islander now in VA - greatly appreciate your podcast! Thanks for all you do

Keep up the great work guys, love the show.

Really entertaining podcast that is easy to find because it is on the same day every week. Chemistry between the two hosts is evident when one misses a show. Just doesn’t feel the same. You hear that Tony? Let’s try not to miss any more shows!!!

Great pod. A lot of useful info. Also one of the longer podcasts. Keep up the great work!

Sean and Tony are diehard islander fans, and their passion shows through in each episode of Hockey Night In New York. They are knowledgeable about the team and hockey in general, and the conversation is intelligent. They break it up with informative guests like Arthur staple and Brian Compton. I would’ve given them five stars, but I’m still annoyed by their show just before the July 1 free agency deadline where they all but had Panerin signed, sealed, and delivered to the Islanders, but that quibble aside, you will not go wrong with Hockey Night In New York

Sean & Tony, For all the great islander coverage you provide, it is severely degraded and tarnished by the extremely poor audio levels within your broadcast. It is unlistenable at points because whoever your guest is has an audio level way too high compared to you guys. In order to hear you both the volume needs to be cranked way up, but then the guests volume blows out the speakers. Also whoever is in charge of the segment entry & exit music needs to be completely removed from the controls as the music is always louder than your voices. Don’t get me wrong, you guys do an amazing job with your information and humorous thoughts and banter, but there needs to be major improvements on the production end. The volume and music levels make the podcast really difficult to tolerate and listen to. Please do something so I can continue to listen. Thanks

Very good content but the sound quality is atrocious. I have to keep the volume turned up to almost max to hear them but the guests come in loud and clear. It really is terrible compared to other “real” podcasts. That said, I DO like the content and topics. It is only that the poor sound makes it almost unlistenable.

Great for Islander fans

Tony and Shawn always provide a great islanders centric show breaking down the weeks games and talking islanders hockey

Love the show but the Audio quality is week. Please update your recording equipment. The static makes the show difficult to listen to. Your content is amazing! Please give the listeners ears a break and fix the audio. Thanks!

Great to find an islanders fan talking hockey. Glad hockey's back.

Great new hockey show! The fact that they do almost all their shows live and in front of audiences makes it truly unique and exciting!