I liked the way your story started off. It was so clear you were doing it for your extended family and for Naomi. It’s sad that there wasn’t much spoken about the grandmother or great grandmother . I’m love what the child said at the end in reference to her great great grandmother.

This subscription in a subscription model is absurd.

Really enjoyed this podcast. This podcast asks a lot of questions about investigating. Investigating crimes, investigating biases, history, ghosts and most importantly-to me-the stories we tell ourselves. Well done!

I loved this series! Super fascinating story! I hope there is a second season with a new story.

Kudos to wonderful for letting this run even if they didn’t have all the answers. I thought it was worth the listen.

Beautiful. Thoroughly enjoyed.

It’s all worth it to bring her memory to light.

Vacuous entertainment. Don’t take on a story as journalist if you can’t surmount your personal conflicts of interest. A compelling story turns superficial and feel good, it appears to preserve Mr. Redman’s family relationships. While I have sympathy for his tension; his bias limited the merit of the project and wasted my time.

...two years later, to hear the rest you need a subscription? COME ON. Sounded intriguing but I won't pay a monthly sub just to hear a podcast. Sorry. People are getting sick of subscription models and this is absurd.

I listened to the first episode and thought it was boring but I was going to give it a chance with the second episode then I realized you need a Wondery+ subscription to proceed on to ep 2. Nope. Too boring to subscribe. Thanks for saving me the time. I can now move on to a better podcast.

This story has it all, is intriguing, suspenseful and really well narrated. Great for a long drive

True Crime, Mystery, History, Genealogy, the Supernatural… shall I continue? It’s all here, and done so well! Desperately hoping for another season & story!

The dumbest story I have ever listened to just a story nothing more

This podcast is more than a true crime. More than a ghost story. Spoiler Alert: The wound to me is that the man may not have been the “hero” disturbs folks more than the erasure of the woman. I would love to know more about Naomi. But she lived her story instead of creating it. I’m glad the young girl was proud to be related to her. Great story telling!

What an amazing twist at the end. Please we need a second season. I need to know more about the faceless woman.

I’m a bit of a true crime podcast snob. I listened to the Season 1 in one day. It’s interesting and surprisingly touching. I wish there were more episodes. And now I mourn the end of an usually excellent podcast. Thank you.

I am a podcast fanatic- and this is - by far - is the best podcast I’ve ever listened to. All of it. The pace, the narrative, the honesty, the self reflection…too much to list. More please.

Excellent work guys! I truly enjoy the story. Hope you will make more stories like this one. Bravo! 👏

I love ghost stories and stuff about haunting along with true crime shows. This podcast is perfect! Interesting, mysterious, haunting but not dark at all. Love it! Well done!

All I can say is I was hanging on to every word! Kate please let Tristen do a season 2 🥹We need more Ghost Stories!

This is such a great podcast. It is very well done and kept me guessing.

Listened to the entire podcast today. I couldn’t step away from it. Well told. Would love another podcast on Ghost Story!

The family reading the memoriam at the end…was one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard

I am only just starting episode 4 after just listening to the first three and I have to add an opinion before I go on. What if Morris was hiding after hearing his sister get shot and locked himself in the bathroom and Dr. Darcy broke it down to get to him to kill him before the “suicide” not after to check on him? There are only 3 people in that home that know the truth and he’s the only one that lived through it. Anyway this podcast has me hooked, well done. I don’t want it to end.

I am two episodes away from the finale, not counting the “burning questions answered” episode. I am dreading the end because I’m enjoying it so much I am afraid I won’t find another one as good as this in short order! This story has captivated me. It’s perfect for spooky season if you’re also into investigative journalism/documentary. The author’s connection to it is also not only supremely unique in itself, it forces the story to be an examination of all of the characters’ potential motives, including the author himself. It’s not often a documentarian admits that along the way, and I appreciated that. I was hooked with the intro ghost stories that brought this story up in the first place, and stayed for the deep dive into these real lives and events that may or may not be connected-overall a great mystery series.

It started off great but definitely fizzled quickly. Many 5 star comments talk about how this podcast honored the forgotten woman who was murdered. All fine and well, but is that the premise you expect from a podcast that’s called “ghost story?” She’s not even the ghost in question! It’s giving bait and switch- let me hook you with this ghost story then dive into my wife’s family drama. Yawn

This is so boring and hard to listen to. I couldn’t get past the first 20 minutes.

An true unsung hero - love, love, love!!!

First, I’m a producer and being pushed towards a show makes me resistant to engaging with it. Within seconds of playing the podcast I was transported to a study in London on a crisp fall day, listening to a “Ghost Story.” I was hooked. The Dancy family history, interwoven with the larger historical relevance is breathtaking and inspiring. Tristan’s and Annie’s reporting, and their openness to exploring alternative methods of research are fun and fascinating. Lastly, I owe the Dancy family a debt of gratitude for letting their story be dissected and shared with the world. This series gave me a much needed respite from the 2024 Presidential Election. Thank you 🙏

I love this show. I’m on episode 4 or 5, can’t quite remember which number, but it’s the one where they go to mediums and the last one is the soft spoken young man. He gets some important things right. And then Tristan starts getting skeptical and defensive when his assistant talks about his reactions. When he brings up the fact that he is worried that “some people, in the future, may be taken in by this” I immediately thought what his assistant thought- you’re not worried about the general public, at some future point, being lied to by a medium! We react from our own sense of self! We react with our own story of who we are! He is a rational male journalist. It’s clear he doesn’t want to experience what he just did. And when he says it feels dark or disturbing- I wish I could ask him why? People die, that’s not a scary thing. We humans have made it seem so. We are energetic electrical beings. We physically leave this earth, but we stay here- our essence and energy do. I just think that because he’s a journalist, he wants to focus on facts. And you can say that it is a fact that when we die, we don’t disappear into a void of nothing- we continue on. It isn’t scary unless you allow yourself to scared! I mean here he is, doing this whole investigation into ghosts and he’s afraid that a person who has passed on is a scary thing! He’s afraid of ghosts.

I haven’t finished but had to stop and share at this point I strongly feel this is more good than harm to share the truth with your daughters- before you started this, you didn’t even know the name Naomi existed in your family. It sounds like she was a strong member of your family. Would love you to continue to investigate more into her life and maybe give your family a positive strong sense of legacy pride- Albeit a different narrative than what they had with the family lies. Naomi sounds to be a strong woman ahead of her time as they say- The breadwinner who helped many families and their children. Bravo on this please keep going

Way to bring to life some amazing and wonderful family members. What an honor, thank you for sharing this story- it’s not about the murder or the ghost- it’s about the people’s lives and achievements you brought back to life and that’s an incredible journey of love. Bravo!

I think shows that feature any kind of "true crime" elements can get exploitative quickly, but this feels like it honors someone who had their story erased and seems to be done very responsibly and with respect for those involved. So good.

Couldn't even get through the first episode. How do you take a premise like this and churn out something so boring?

It’s well made. But in the end it’s not that exciting

I had to binge this podcast! It is amazing what Naomi had to do in death to ensure that her family remembered her and knew the amazing woman she was. May they never forget!

Really wonderful. Hard to believe though that this guy confesses to murder in his memoirs, his letters, a phone call, and a song, and people still don’t believe he did it. Feyther only cared about his legacy; if children are part of your legacy it is easy to love them. And Feyther got his way: everyone forgot his remarkable wife and only talks about the self-possessed narcissist. Amazing how he manipulated generations, but still felt guilty enough to leave confessions all over.

I can’t fully express how much I appreciated this story but I truly was hooked from the beginning and I couldn’t put it down till it was done. What a fantastic and reflective story teller.

Thoughtful, intriguing and tenderly done work, all well done! Binge listened to the whole thing every chance I got, and have shared this gem with everyone I know. Kudos to all involved, and many hugs to the family in navigating such a delicate journey through their own timeline.

I was immediately hooked on this podcast. It’s the first time I created housework and laundry to do, so I can continue to listen to this story. I love Tristan’s narrative…sometimes playful and pokes fun of himself, yet intertwined with mystery and suspense. I felt the emotions of the Dancy family and their conflicted emotions they experienced having their treasured family legacy questioned. In the end, what matters is that Naomi, who was nearly forgotten in the family legacy, came to surface and the profound accomplishments she achieved ahead of her time. Bravo Tristan! By the way, my favorite part is having your talented brother in law read the bulletins…his accent and delivery sucked me in, as if it was actually Father’s voice. Amazing!

This show has everything I love in a story: true crime, ghosts, family drama, and London. I wish I could listen to it for the first time all over again.

A total waste of time.

I tried my best to find interest in this and to actually pay attention to it, but I just couldn’t like I paid attention to it but it just never seemed interesting when I had heard the preview for it. It seemed really interesting I was kind of low-key, hoping for more of the ghost stories and less of the family drama.

This felt like grasping at straws. While the people themselves are compelling, it’s just loose threads behind the metaphor of a ghost story.

Beautiful, engaging, human, thoughtful and so well done. Real quality journalism and story-telling among the wasteland that is true crime podcasts.

It’s fantastic, a real Agatha Christie murder mystery with an an appearance by Dorothy Sayers?! Say no more-It’s stunning. Listen if you love historical true crime. Brilliant.

I absolutely loved this podcast! From the moment I started it, I couldn’t wait to find out the next twist or what else was hiding around the corner. It is also an amazing tribute to Naomi, someone who it seems very much deserved to be recognized. Well done! 👏🏼

One of my favorite podcasts ever listened to. The ending was such a good conclusion to the story. Engaging, and I loved all the players in the storytelling.

Great story and kept me very interested. However, the background music and violin was way too dramatic! Became a bit annoying.

This show was so engaging and so well done. I binged the entire thing in one day. Really hoping that Tristan and Annie find another spooky story to investigate.