Just discovered it and love it. Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys, Encyclopedia Brown, etc…And it’s funny!

I have been known as a Nancy Drew enthusiast for many years, and this show is the perfect amount of enjoying the series and seeing it for its ridiculousness. The rating system is really maybe the best part of the show! Funny, creative way to enjoy the mysteries.

Karen and Kelly are a total joy, and both I and my eleven year old daughter, who has dressed up as Nancy Drew more than once, take delight in their reviews of Nancy Drew mysteries!

I grew up with Nancy Drew and love mysteries of all kinds. The sisterly banter and obvious love is icing on the cake.

This is the podcast I’ve been waiting my whole life for! (Well, not literally as there was no such thing as podcasts for much of my life, but you take my point.). I love the discussion of the Nancy Drew books, as well as the special episode “super sleuth” books. I really love how these two sisters genuinely love and relate to each other. Twelve out of twelve old clocks!

Terry Scott fascinates me ! Look forward to you writing a book so that he and Nancy can be together again.

It is so much fun to listen to these two sisters chat about Nancy Drew (and adjacent topics). Their affection for each other and their shared sense of humor is a delight to listen to.

I absolutely adore your banter! I could listen to you guys talk about anything and keep on keeping on ♥️

Thank you Karen and Kelly, wonderful podcast. It is basically a Nancy drew book club. Also I found a River heights in Utah, and I found out that the author for the “Hardy boys” and “Nancy Drew” is the same author under two different names. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts about the Nancy Drew books I love this podcast.

I have binged all of the episodes in the last few weeks and felt like I could not get enough of this podcast - so fun and entertaining! Thanks for bringing this podcast into our lives and sharing your lives and often hilarious (and on point!) insights into the Nancy Drew series!

Really enjoying the sisters reviews about Nancy Drew and other mysteries. Feels like a conversation I could jump into easily! Enjoy the laughs and remembering the joy of reading my “ Nancy Drew” books

Karen and Kelly have provided me with the most reliably humorous and entertaining podcast episodes in the year 2022. I really treasured those stress-free and laugh out loud minutes. I hope there are many more episodes to come.

I love to listen to Kelly and Karen review Nancy Drew books (and cook weird food).

Very entertaining, funny repartee between the sisters. I loved Nancy Drew as a child so this is a great way to relive those plots with a modern view.

As a commuter I am constantly trying to find a podcast that makes my ride a little more enjoyable. I grew up reading Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys and would laugh along with them. Now I get to relive them with the delightful hosts Kelly and Karen as well as discover new YA mysteries to read! Join the hilarious party that will make you wish you were popping a white claw and enjoying a baked good along with them!

The dynamic between the two hosts is just too good. A very funny and insightful take on the books. Love it.

I love the dynamic between Karen and Kelly and the love their takes on the books! Such a fun listen!

Compelling, comprehensive, hysterical and ever so insightful that even my cat enjoys listening! Prepare yourself for clues, questions, mystery solving, and laughter. This podcast is welcoming and fun. Rated 11.5 out of 12 Podcast microphones 🎙

I love this podcast. I was an avid Nancy Drew fan and have many memories of browsing the library looking for yet another Nancy Drew mystery I hadn’t read. I wish I could find the book I owned where I checked off each book as I read it. This podcast brings it all back and adds a fun spin. I love the sisters’ analysis of the stories 😂 And really, how is Nancy so adept at so many things?? I just reread the Mystery of Phantom Ranch and she is a skilled rider, knows how to diagnose what’s wrong with a car, and is an amazing sleuth. Not to mention she’s a titian haired fashionista! I find myself looking for chores, just so I can join Karen, Kelly, and Nancy in another exciting mystery!

I read about this podcast in the NYTimes recently and have been working my way through the episodes. It has been a highlight of my summer! Such fun and it brings back wonderful memories of my father reading me Nancy Drew when I was a girl. The sweet sisterly banter and wit of the hosts make me smile and laugh out loud every episode. Thank you for making this podcast and please make more episodes!

The honest take on Nancy and the gang is hilarious and so so true! I still keep a stack of Nancy Drew by my bed for when I’m feeling anxious. Glad there are so many books..cause that means many more episodes ♥️

I started listening because the New York Times recommended this podcast recently and I was a Nancy Drew fan growing up. I love the easy conversation and have laughed out loud several times while listening. I hope they come back and do more episodes, im running out quickly!

Such a fun and nostalgic podcast. Love this sister duo! Would love to hear a Hardy Boys spin-off!

One of my favorite podcasts. I love Nancy Drew and spending time with Karen and Kelly is so enjoyable! It reminds me of school bus conversations as my friends and I would compare notes on what we read or watched the night before. Nancy Drew, the Hardy Boys, and Trixie Belden books were always shared among us and we would then talk about their adventures like they were our own. I hope all is well with Karen and Kelly. I keep checking for new episodes, but in the meantime I listen to the archive and enjoy each replay. Karen and Kelly: If you are able to continue this podcast I will be so happy to share the adventure. But if you guys are not okay, please know that you are missed.

I grew up loving the Nancy Drew video games, so naturally I was curious about the books! I love the fun dynamic that this podcast has, both hosts are absolutely hilarious and great storytellers. This podcast doesn’t just cover the plot lines, it analyzes these books in a fun way with lots of absolutely entertaining commentary. I find myself listening to it while I’m winding down for the day, doing stuff around the house, or even cutting my grass. It’s a definitely favorite to go to!

If you took My Favorite Murder and made it something that was actually good, consistent, funny, and thoughtful, and had talented hosts, you’d have this podcast.

I really enjoy this podcast. I’m kinda hopping around as I read the Nancy Drew books, but you really don’t have to. They give great summaries and character descriptions so reading the books is not needed. The commentary is funny and thoughtful. The podcast feels so unscripted and conversational but so entertaining. I’ll be back to listen to more for sure!

These two sisters crack me up and I laugh out loud with the drop dead sincere delivery of sarcasm. Recaps of great vintage YA mystery books are not that common and this one is definitely a keeper! They have great chemistry and as sisters, they have shared stories that go WAY back. Have really enjoyed listening! Keep it up!

Kelly and Karen are HILARIOUS! I love their sister dynamic and how they add comedy in reviewing some of the best young adult mysteries so many of us read as kids. I’m really just obsessed with the hosts. This is my favorite podcast to listen to in the morning.

If you haven’t heard this podcast yet - get a clue! One of my favorite podcasts and I love their Nancy Drew coverage and other fun discussions. It’s no mystery that they’re 10/10 magnifying glasses :)

This podcast has only had a few episodes so far and I’m already watching for my feed to update! The hosts are funny and insightful and their sister dynamic is charming. I read more of the later-published Nancy Drews, and I’m enjoying this window into the rest of the series. One of my favorite parts is how they talk a little bit about what was happening in the country when the books were published, so we can better understand things like, why are people so obsessed with bonds? My only complaint so far is that i can’t binge this pod yet!

Fabulous podcast with witty hosts. Love going back and look at all these old young adult mysteries we read so many years ago. Keep up the good work girls !

Well-produced, tight review show with fun segments and the right amount of host banter. The first two review episodes were lots of fun. I look forward to listening to more!

Have you ever wished you could play Oregon Trail one more time? Watch one more episode of Hey, Dude? This podcast gives us a chance to revisit one more indulgent pastime and that’s YA mysteries. Did you have a favorite? I sure did and after re-reading it, man, it did not age well for 2021. I can’t wait to discuss.