I’m not sure what the point of the guy on this show is. He doesn’t add any useful content and honestly seems kind of out of it most of the time. There are definitely moments that are questionable and judgmental, but that’s bound to happen. Other than that it can be interesting.

I’ve never heard of this podcast until trash Trevino got put on it and in the YouTube video she gave a shout out to her effort to help Palestine, an immediate follow on all platforms. I’m very much looking forward to listening to past and future podcasts

I’ve been watching since the mukbang days & every story is always told amazingly by Stephanie soo & the input from her husband is always on point! It’s like he asks the questions I have in my mind 😂 thank you for all your work!!!

Instantly hooked, however, I cannot immerse myself in the worst of humanity. This is just awful. I felt slimy long after listening. The host however deserves a Wendy Williams crown. She’s amazing!!! The show is unhealthy and genius! Bravo!!

Just stumbled upon this podcast and I have to say I’m super impressed. She goes so in depth on everything and doesn’t leave a single leaf unturned. This podcast has definitely joined my regular rotation.

She’s amazing at telling the documents/stories!

I love her podcast and I always listen to her to get my school work done all in all she’s the best

Luv u❤️

I love Stephanie- she does such a great job winding through her stories in a passionate and well written way! I know some people don’t like that she inserts her own opinion, but it’s one of my favorite things about her. I love the international stories and being able to see the parallel of human nature in all societies so keep that up please!!! I know that on YouTube, you have to censor yourself to not get dinged and that’s my only complaint about this podcast. Is the use of the R word and SA-I don’t think it does any justice for the victims to water down what was done to them. If we are choosing to speak of these crimes, we should not be allowed to make it more palatable for ourselves to say or hear- being sexually assaulted or raped is not palatable to those that have experienced it and it is not okay for the world to try and make it so.

Random suggestion, but what if you had Mango with you while you chat? I’m new(ish) to the podcast so not sure if Mango has actually joined us yet. I think listening to this has helped me understand some of the chaos of the world and it’s heartbreaking to know that some people are just heartless and will do these horrible things just out of greed. I also like all the conspiracy theories, I’m not sure. I guess I like how it gets my brain going and think more deeply to the point where I’m stuck in bed for 6 HOURS. Love this podcast so much! <3

The host is a great storyteller. She does a lot of research and tells her stories with both enthusiasm and sympathy.

You are a fabulous story teller, just realized it’s just that a story. Your Ash Trevino episode, really highlights your gifted story telling abilities. You really should try to be less Orion Willian, and give frequent updates that the audience is listening to fiction. Keep up the fabulous work, but add the warning “Label”

You should do a show or 2 about Nicolas Claux in France that lived in the castle

I love this podcast! Great research and I love your voice❤️

I’ve always loved podcasts about true crimes, and for me Rotten Mango is the best choice! It is a fantastic podcast exploring well-chosen crime stories, accompanied by decent research and a well-practiced narrator. I especially love how Stephanie makes every crime seem like a personalized story. The only small problem I have with this is how sometimes Stephanie makes a big deal about small details of crime (for example, if a mom is convicted of murder, Stephanie kind of over-analyzes everything the mom did before the murder, acting like she’s a horrible mom, even though the mom was acting normally). Overall, this is still a cool podcast that I will definitely be updated on! Strongly recommend🥳(would give this 4.5 ⭐️rating)

I love the fact that her show has her HUSBAND that’s called a team!!! I think it’s cute that he’s engaged and involved.. it helps me b/c he be asking and expressing what I be wanting to know 😅.. go HUBBY 🙌🏽🙌🏽👍🏽🎉🎉🎉 I’m all caught up on her podcast.. I just started last year with listening. Yeah I’m hooked 🤷🏽‍♀️😩😂 I even took note of some of her desserts when she was doing the baking a mystery

I really enjoy listening to your podcast.

LOVE MY GIRLLLL

Great story teller 👍👍

Stephanie has such a unique and intriguing way of unfolding a story and finding the most interesting cases. I love the questions her co-host asks, and the amount of his participation. This is currently my favorite podcast. Thank you both and your researchers!

Stephanie, you have such a unique way of telling each story. Thank you!

Used to be a good show but last few years it’s just an obnoxious PC woman telling men how bad they are and her lap boy saying yes because he knows where his bread is buttered!

I'm literally in LOVE with watching her, she goes into so much detail and it's just amazing how she describes everything.

I stumbled upon this podcast and was immediately hooked.

She explains each story with such detail and her husband asks the questions the listeners want to ask so it just feels like we're part of the conversation !

I always go back and listen to the episodes over and over again! I started watching Stephanie on Youtube but this podcast is an amazing production in audio format. Stephanie and her fiancé don't just talk about the case, they go into the background of the subject, the life of the victims. The episodes are so detailed I feel as though I really grasp the story with emotion and I feel for the subjects involved.

My daughter loves you!!!

I love how Stephanie Soo narrates and tells stories, I can listen to her every single day!

This is one of my favorite podcasts. I love that her husband chimes in and is usually surprised by the details. Stephanie is engaging and tells stories marvelously. She’s very respectful of the content and victims. Yes, she has opinions, but I enjoy them. I like that she never strays off point; too many podcasts get sidetracked

I love Stephanies personality and energy. it seems to lighten the load of scary and traumatic info but still cuts deep enough to make you feel, yk? but her husband and her are like the best duo. its funny to hear his reactions and the questions he asks, because they're actually helpful and relatable questions. i think Stephanie deserves more credit for how much time and work into making an interesting, informative and deep podcast all in one. anyways thank you soso much stephanie you are lovedd 💞🫶🏼

I am obsessed with this podcast, the story telling is amazing, captivating, and precise. My favorite part is Stephanie’s personal comments and giggles, I feel like I am on a phone call with my bestie telling me a story. Highly recommend!!

Ok this is my fav true crime podcast for sure!! I see a lot of reviews saying they don’t like the cohost, but he makes it a lot better imo! they’re very sweet together and he slows down the story if it ever gets a little confusing. it’s such a good pod!!

If you're on the lookout for a podcast that strikes the perfect balance between entertainment and true crime, look no further! This podcast is an absolute gem that delivers incredibly informative content, wrapped in engaging storytelling. From the moment you hit play, you can tell that each episode is meticulously researched. The hosts have a knack for breaking down complex topics into digestible and relatable narratives, making it easy to grasp even the most intricate details. Their commitment to accuracy and trustworthiness is evident, ensuring that you're getting the most reliable information available. Highly recommend!

I am absolutely obsessed with this podcast! Her storytelling technique honestly drags you into the gruesome minds of these people. And her husband’s reactions are so funny😭 it feels like you’re listening in on tea with a friend that keeps reacting! Love it! Please continue what you do and NEVER get discouraged. Lyyyyy💗🫶🏽

Steph and her team do such detailed research and her story telling skills are fantastic!

I love your pod I listen to it after and on my way to school. When I have my free period I listen. But can you tune it down to more murder I feel wrong listening to things with little kids. Especially with little kids and sa

It isn’t well researched and the way she talks is ridiculous

I’ve enjoyed Stephanie’s storytelling of stories that I’ve actually never heard of or are not widely spoken about! I don’t understand the role of the “co-host” guy that just chimes in here and there. I feel like he’s barely getting the storylines or the points and doesn’t contribute anything at all for me. I think the show would benefit from removing him or introducing a more engaging co-host that actually asks intriguing questions or makes interesting points as opposed to “ohhh really?” “What the heck” “wow” …… Have to take two whole stars off for him

I wasn't into true crime for the longest time. No clue why but my algorithm kept recommending it to me anyway. Eventually, I caved. So, I gave this one a shot and now I am a true crime fan/junkie 😂😂😂

This is my third podcast and it is absolutely amazing. If you love gory topics and true crime this is the best podcast for you. I’m only on the second episode and this is amazing. I watch Stephanie’s YouTube channel and this is right up my alley it is the best mix of gore and drama. SOOOOO GOOD

listened to one whole podcast and dont think I'll listen more. passionate presentation is engaging and an easy listen As much as they like to research, host likes to judge too definitely. Sees things far too black and white. and it's a poison to the work.

Her story telling really brings such humanity and realness to the victims and cases. The amount of adds some times is a bit annoying but the amazing quality of the podcast makes up for it. Oh and thank you for supporting Palestine!

I’ve been a fan since before you were sponsored by cold and have never stopped listening!

Ever day I get home I grab a snack and a blanket and turn on this podcast. I don’t know how but so how this podcast is comforting.

Please stop saying “self-exit”. No need to use an infantilized tiktok phrase in place of died by suicide.

i love this podcast i’m just not paying $4 a month for 2 podcasts.

I love her this podcast is amazing

My favorite podcast ever I’ve been watching her mukbangs on YouTube for years then I found her podcast I’ve listened every one and just sit and wait every week for another to drop. M.O.T.S is my second favorite but I really miss the B.A.M podcast.

its a really amazing podcast i love so much!! but i keep getting glitches in my audio.

This is the best true crime podcast out there. Stephanie is very informative and does a good job at talking about cases I haven’t heard of before. It’s always something new with this podcast. It keeps me busy on my long car drives and while I’m at work. 10/10 would recommend .