This is my favorite podcast. I can’t wait every week for a new one. I’ve done listened to every one of them at least twice.

Excellent state to finish

Always producing consistently great content. Love you James & Jimmy! (Every time I hear you say pocket robin I hear the song Rockin’ Robin in my head 🤣🎶)

My favorite

Oh Jimmie😂 “say again” James “what” Jimmie” the head facing what!?” Jimmie: “Wow” James: “what” Jimmie: “that means his head is on backwards” James: “what?” James: “Am I confused? No, it’s you” I’m dying 💀

My favorite podcast. Love your delivery, extensive research, and senses of humor. Excellent all the way.

Can’t wait to see you guys in the Lou!

I just started listening to your podcast. I have gone back to the very first episode and listened my way to your current one. I absolutely love your podcast, it has gotten me through my work weeks. Keep up the great job. You guys are so funny. Love it.

I’ve listened to them all and have started over

❤️

I love this podcast so much!

THE HARDEST WORKING PODCASTERS AROUND. STM: / Episode length: 165 mins. / Fluff time, round-up: 27 mins. / Avg time between fluff: 33 mins. / Fluff%: 17%. / Based on episode: 559. Intro: It can be up to 7-mins to SUAGMM. ========================== STM EXPRESS: FLUFF SCORE. 18% / Episode length: 80 mins / Ads + Fluff ⭕️ ⬆️: 14 mins. / Avg time between ads: 20 mins. / Based on episode: 560 ============================

Funny and informative. Better than all the douche celebrity podcasts

Im not a true crime fan but these guys are hilarious and do a great job of choosing great and weird cases.

Great true crime show - a must listen!

The true crime parts are insanely amazing, but I love when they do the Real Estate Report and reviews of the town. A great deep dive of facts for each story and make me wonder if any of my neighbors could be as crazy as some of these people.

It’s a tree 🤣🤣

.... Deliver the best murder porn!

I love listening to all of their shows but this one is my favorite. It’s clear that James puts in a lot of time to research these cases. And Jimmie interjects comments and jokes perfectly. Keep up the great work guys! - From a grateful turkey

Crawfish is my favorite food .

I’m a true crime fan, and a comedy fan. It was CRAZY to think I could find both in one podcast, but these guys bring it. The show is respectful of victims but they hilariously destroy the perps and other aspects of the towns, crimes, investigators, etc. Three thumbs up!

These two make me laugh. Favorite sandwich is Grilled Cheese. Now shut up and give me some murder!

Love Love Love! I just started over from the beginning for the third time. Every episode is worth the listen!! So good...

Love Montana

Absolutely love listening to you guys! Completely hooked!

Simultaneously intensely researched and beyond hilarious.

Been a long time listener and show attendee!! James and Jimmy never disappoint with the dive deep start to finish, all the while cracking me up! Love it!!

Obsessed in the most non-creepy way. Keep up the amazing work guys!

I like you guys AND Keith Morrison.

Went back and started from the beginning..only on episode 166..the craziest one yet

I found this podcast semi-recently and have been binging it nonstop, and now looking into tickets to see them live. I don’t know if it’s because I’m from a small town that deserves the slander, or because of the intense research every episode, or because I love the banter, but I absolutely love these guys. This is one of the few true crime podcasts that I actively look forward to and always recommend to others. The best!

A perfect mix of goofball and chill dude. Keep me awake on a boring trek, OR lull me to sleep with a safe and comfortable storytelling….These guys are a true gift to the podcasting universe. I am so happy to have found them.

I just started listening to this podcast and for somebody who doesn’t get hooked easily, I’m hooked. I’ve been listening to the Maine episodes first because that is where I am from, and they are interesting and hilarious, especially the pronunciations of the town names. I love listening to the reviews of the town, especially the one of Sanford because that’s where I’m from. My only thing with the podcast that bugs me is when you guys shout “shut up and give me murder” it’s a bit chaotic…but it adds to the fun of it. Worth the listen!

Pasta is good, pizza is better

True crime and comedy! What could be better. I have been listening since 2019 and can’t stop, won’t stop!

I really can’t say enough how much I love this podcast and James and Jimmie; they are both so hilarious, smart, have done such thorough research, and the show is so engaging and interesting… this podcast has gotten me through some really tough times in my life, funny enough that it’s about murder! But really, you guys have added something really special into the world and it has brought me so much joy, companionship, and intrigue. Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you! Yaaaaayyyyyyyyyy!

This is by far the best podcast out there! My favorite podcast for sure!

James and Jimmie provide excellent storytelling, commentary and hilarity in every well researched episode. These guys work their butts off over their 3 podcasts including ‘Crime in Sports’ and ‘Your Stupid Opinions’ and regularly post even more original content to their Patreon account.

409 lol

Just started listening about a week ago and started from episode one. I’m 12 episodes in and have ugly laughed I don’t even know how many times. Current new fave podcast for sure

Hope this helps Al Gore.

My favorite podcasters

I might stalk you guys

I forgot about that video!! Love it

This pod makes my boring daily chores enjoyable!

These guys are hilarious! New listener here so I’m catching up, and for clarity, you’re right Alabama is a cesspool 😂

Never a dull moment with James and Jimmy!

Y’all play off each other and it’s hilarious. Grape jelly is better than strawberry. I said what I said.

A guy I was chatting with on a dating app told me about this podcast back in like 2019. The guy didn’t work out, but I’m now a hardcore fan of EVERYTHING James and Jimmie do! They are the best in the biz and truly deliver for their fans. I listen to a LOT of podcasts but these are the absolute best of the best. STM, CIS, YSO and the patreon episodes have gotten me through some really tough times. Huge thank you to the guys and everyone else who makes these episodes happen. I’m a murder Turkey for life!

🎶 “ Ohh I lovvve grape jellllyyy!”